famous conflict of interest cases

hoa fine schedule examples

10 de março de 2023

Owner will be warned in writing or email 2. another 1st Notice; they will receive a 2nd Notice and additional fines. stream before the Board of Directors (or their appointed designees) to address the Burke is Gladly's top industry expert. Within15 days of the notice of fine, the homeowner may request to meet with members of the Association Board topresent pertinent information that bears upon his/her situation. On the other hand, larger violations may warrant larger fines, especially if the violation has serious consequences such as risking the safety of other members or economic losses. The following fine schedule shall apply to all violations: 1st Violation: $50.00-$300.00 for initial violation; 2nd Violation: $100.00-$500.00 for 2nd separate violation; 3rdrd separate violation. One common point of contention has to do with HOA fines. c. The board will send the homeowner written notice of the violation to the homeowners address ofrecord. More importantly, they'll reinforce the value that your association provides to your owners every day they live in your community. The Board may re-assess a fine if: Most HOAs that have fine policies charge a minimum of $25.00 for an initial violation. The attorney also usually writes the template letter that goes out with a fine." Some Basic Fine Amounts. The Meados HOA at Perry Hall Farms The Meadows at Perry Hall Farms HOA Fine Schedule and Enforcement Policy Below is the Enforcement Policy and Fine Schedule for the Meadows at Perry Hall Farms community. Civil Code Section 4355. "text":"Should a homeowner fail to pay the fine, the HOA board can turn to one of two ways to ensure collection: take the issue to Small Claims Court or to the Superior Court."} hVRJ~tFdNg PNoqvRWc; IO+m.>\aBu6r thX0 >m6pe6e9>t%-t%$ c?@j |!,c lkFv3#Kve_[L]~;gFsGO The original fine amount will be $100. a judge, arbiter, etc.) Too small an amount will not deter homeowners from breaking the rules, while a fine too large might be considered extortion. [GC$uK}/s 9}Y>$ The Enforcement Policy and Fine Schedule for the Bluegrass Meadows Community is designed to maintain the image of our highly sought-after community and maintain house values for all property owners. regarding approval of fines and commencement of the Fine Committee hearing process for any or all of the owners on the report that do not comply with the Association's demands within the time frames set forth in the violation letters. endobj When HOA boards draft Notice of Decision letters, they should be written in such a way that a person who is unfamiliar with the case (e.g. Rule and a description of their violation. Interestingly though, the California statute does not require that the amount of potential fines be distributed on the same schedule. The HOA also has the right to sue you if you don't fix the problem or pay your fines. Click to reveal For violation number 7 (ACC Application Violations), the ACC will impose an immediate fine of $500.00 followed by a fine of $100.00 per week until the ACC Application is submitted. In this new and expanded special report, we lay the groundwork for your board to draft For example, does the schedule have to break down each possible violation and the corresponding fine amount (i.e., $25 for trash cans left out, $50 for unapproved construction, $100 for parking in the street, etc. It would be unreasonable to levy a $200 fine against a homeowner who simply failed to clean up after their dog. The original fine will be $400 for each tree cut down. Flexible. 4. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. For example, sometimes a violation must be discussed at an HOA board meeting before the HOA can take any action. Your HOA can fine you until you address the issue. The Board will send the homeowner written notice of the fine to thehomeowners address of record. 102 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<775BDC557313B642AE2611B64C9D314E>]/Index[83 37]/Info 82 0 R/Length 96/Prev 113067/Root 84 0 R/Size 120/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream Schedule of Monetary Penalties (Fines). If any construction, change or alteration is not made compliant,additional fines may be imposed as set forth in paragraph B above. When deciding how much to fine someone, it is important not to set the amount too low or too high. d. If the violation is not corrected within the 15 day period or otherwise abated by the Board, theoriginal fine is $100. Short answer, yes. "text": "When deciding how much to fine someone, it is important not to set the amount too low or too high. Civil Code Section 5310. Your HOA . Repeat Violations: A repeat violation occurs when a person violates the same provision of the Associations governing document more than once within a two-year period and was given appropriate warnings about the previous violation. homeowner. hb```f``d`a`dg@ ~+sS10 Further, nes can be imposed from the day the work began, after the appropriate notice has been sent and the homeowners have had time to submit a written letter or email response to the board. Repeat violations may be assessed a ne on a weekly basis beginning one-week after the repeat violation is noticed and a letter is sent notifying the homeowner of the violation. ", September 01, HOA Fine Schedules: An Example A: Based on your description of what happened, it does not appear right to us that different people would get fined different amounts for the same exact violation. In short, it is a way for board members to deal with residents who disobey rules without immediately resorting to legal action. Typically, an HOA violation letter will include information regarding the offense, a declaration stating the HOAs laws or rules that were violated, a compliance date, suggestions on how to solve the problem, a fine amount, and a . AB-1572 (Friedman) Potable water: nonfunctional turf. e. If the violation is not corrected within the 15 days of the notice of violation or otherwise abated bythe Board, the original fine will be of an amount equal to the greater of $100 OR the cost of cleaningup or properly maintaining the building, yard and/or landscaping of the property that is not properlymaintained. Noise. Example: If the 1st fine is $100 1st fine - original fine amount $100 2nd fine - original fine amount $100 If an association adopts a policy for imposing fines, Civil Code Section 5850 requires the association to adopt a schedule of fines that may be imposed for violations, and to distribute the fine schedule to the membership as part of the associations annual policy statement. The letter will identify the nature of the A courtesy letter citing the specific violation(s) and An Alternative to Using Set Amounts for HOA Fines. Some governing documents explicitly state the boards authority to impose fines, while others only imply it. It has come to the attention of the homeowners association that a violation of our bylaws has occurred. C. The homeowners address of record will be the: a. Homeowners contact address listed with the Thurston County Assessors Office, and/or. As mandated by C.R.S. H. Violation of the covenants (Covenants Article III Permitted and Prohibited Uses, paragraph {y}), Subsection (y) Homeowners of record are responsible for ensuring that their property ismaintained, including normal and expected upkeep of buildings and landscaping. 2 0 obj Three Templates Every HOA Should Have! 2 0 obj Should the same or similar rule be violated more than three times, the Association Board shall be empowered to impose a larger fine stream Whats The Impact Of Remote Workers On The Housing Market? Code 4355(a)(3).) This above list is not complete or comprehensive. "author": { Repeat Schedule of Fines: The HOA will levy nes for following violations of the association CC&R's: 1) Landscape Maintenance Violations 2) Trash Can Storage Violations 3) Vehicle Violations 4) Noise Ordinance Violations 5) Architectural Violations 6) Yard Installation Violations a. a. "https://cedarmanagementgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/AdobeStock_1262012111.jpg" . . endstream endobj 84 0 obj <> endobj 85 0 obj <>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 86 0 obj <>stream From time to time, the Board or its agents may do property inspections This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. Apparently, Mulcahy finds the minimal requirement of communicating rules and penalties to members of the association to be unreasonable and burdensome. Fines will be levied for failure to comply with the covenants, as follows: a. If your governing documents contain no such provisions, consider amending them to grant the HOA board that power. <>/XObject<>/Pattern<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 612 792] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. 7 Valentines Day Recipes Youll Surely Enjoy This Hearts Day. While warning letters sometimes get the job done, people are warier about following rules when there are monetary penalties. }, The HOA board determines fine amounts and whether they're reasonable. But if you fly your flag without permission, expect to get fined. for you to work with your attorney to craft policies that comply with your governing documents policies and procedures governing a broad scope of board practices and community ", H. Violation of the covenants Covenants Article III.1 (y), I. Your IP: (Civ. violation(s), date, time and location of the hearing. If the fines are too low, they will be viewed by some as a fee for the right to break the rules. Copy. Some associations have light HOA fine policies, while others enforce them more aggressively. The primary option associations use to enforce rules is the imposition of monetary penalties or fines. requesting correction of said vioaltion(s). Homeowners are responsible for damage caused to the common area. <> When a resident commits a violation the first time, you can let them get away with it with just a warning letter. It is not advisable, though, to perpetually increase the fine amount. % There should be a maximum or a limit; otherwise, the fine could blow up to unreasonable proportions. The payment of any and all legal fees and costs incurred by the Association Lets find out. violation of an ongoing nature which has not been corrected.). "datePublished": "2019-09-11T16:05:00+08:00", The homeowner is responsible for any common area damaged "name": "The Cedar Management Group Team" 3. Payment of a fine by the homeowner does not discharge the homeowners obligation to ensure that theconstruction, change or alteration of a building, fence, wall or other structure complies with the covenantsand the standards of this community. If the original fine amount was $100, then the first and second ongoing noncompliance fineamounts will be $200 each). endobj The Board may excuse the fine if. If they do it again, you can charge them $25, and then $50 for the third time. The covenants and bylaws state that the association may file a lien against a property for delinquentassessment. 2. Should a homeowner fail to pay the fine, the HOA board can turn to one of two ways to ensure collection: When defining your HOA fine policies, it is essential to consider homeowner rights and state laws. When it comes to completing these tasks, efficiency and organization are paramount. A: Under NRS 116.31175 (5), a homeowner can request a copy of the general violation record of the community. ( Civ. Can The Board Make Decisions In An HOA Without Consulting Homeowners? Board of Directors will notify the homeowner, in writing, of its decision. For example, if your neighbors decide to throw a wild party at 2 a.m., your HOA will mediate the dispute . From collections policies to rules governing architectural controls, from towing to drones, and from handling conflicts of interest to handling requests for disability accommodations, each of the sample policies in this special report will help you as a board member or educate your members on their responsibilities. behalf, a monetary penalty will then be imposed against the homeowner. Fine Schedule (online version) SEASONS HOA SCHEDULE OF FINES Effective February 13, 2019 ( Printer Friendly pdf) INDEX A. "@type": "BlogPosting", Should the homeowner not show up or an agreement cannot be made during the hearing, the board can consider taking the offender to a small claims court. Due date for HOA intervention (approximately 14 days from receipt of 2nd Notice) and right to correct the violation- reference to CC&Rs Section 8.8 {Example: The homeowner does not edge the property after the 1st Notice. An association can levy a fine against a resident who has broken the rules, provided the authority is granted to the board by the governing documents. %PDF-1.6 % 5 0 obj The bylaws and CC&Rs commonly also include procedures the HOA must follow when taking any action to enforce the rules. week. Each Rule is subject to a separate fine and violation. This is the second purpose of HOA fines. The Texas Residential Property Owners Protection Act is the state law that covers various issues such as board governance, elections and voting, record-keeping and an owner's right to access records, protections regarding third-party collections, required notices, foreclosures for assessment liens, and regulations on leases. Immediate action was necessary because the tree posed imminent danger to any person or property,ORb. regulations. The letter will identify the nature of the violation and the date a response is required before a monetary penalty is assessed (see ne schedule). Second Violation Notice: A letter sent requesting the Homeowner to submit a written or email response to the Board of Directors (or their appointed designees) to address the cited violation(s). Within 15 days of the notice of fine, the homeowner may request to meet with members of the AssociationBoard to present pertinent information that bears upon his/her situation. There may be a repeat, continuing violation, in which case fines (which have 1 0 obj For example, a $25 fine that may be significant to owners in one association may be pocket change to owners in another. <> The penalties for ongoing noncompliance are: a. Code 5310 (a) (8), 5850 (a) .) <> Here are 10 steps that can be set in motion in your community: Step 1: Form the Committee: Board of directors must create a fining committee (also called covenant/fining/grievance/violation committee). Moreover, it is a good idea to adopt an escalating system for your HOA fine policies. To encourage people to pick up after their dogs, for example, an association may set higher fines of $100 or more for this particular violation. Unauthorized disposing of debris in any community common area or damage to any common area or stormwater drainage areas. "acceptedAnswer": { Enforcement Policy . Beginning Tuesday, August 17, 2021, at approximately 2:35, an unauthorized leisure vehicle was parked in the front yard of your home. E.Failure to get prior written approval for construction or alteration, F. Failure to get prior written approval before cutting down a tree. %PDF-1.5 b. The Homeowner is ultimately responsible for any violation of HOA standards and are liable for all nes imposed by the HOA on their property. endstream endobj startxref There were compelling reasons that prevented the homeowner from obtaining prior writtenapproval. Monetary penalties serve two purposes: enforcement and deterrence. Data Security In HOAs: How Is Homeowner Information Protected. Although it cannot exceed $100, a fine can be levied every day that a violation occurs. 3. Failure to pay annual or special assessment. ), Amending the Fine Policy & Fine Schedule A lot of decorations make noise, and . 12-10-801 (3) (a) (IV), the HOA Information Center has compiled a list of "Frequently Asked Questions" and answers for homeowners, board members, and other interested parties, regarding living in and governing a common interest . to enforce violations or collect fines shall be the responsibility of the There were other compelling reasons that prevented the homeowner from obtaining prior writtenapproval. The HOA fined my client for posting a 'Trump For President' in 2016 sign on his front lawn." "Our legal argument before the court was predominantly based on that the First Amendment which we argued allowed a person to freely express themselves, including the posting of a political sign in the front yard. The schedule of fines for infractions is designed to provide an escalating schedule of fines for violations of the same rule repeatedly by an Owner or Owner Party. Ongoing noncompliance is defined as the third or subsequent violation within 12 months of the date of thefirst fine and after receiving a second subsequent fine for the same violation within the 12 month period. Once a fine has reached $1000, a lien may be placed against the resident's property. e. The Board may excuse a fine if the homeowner can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the Board avalid reason why the violation cannot or should not be corrected. "acceptedAnswer": { Below, find eight unenforceable HOA rules, plus a few HOA loopholes: 1. The payment of any and all legal fees and costs incurred by the Association to enforce violations or collect nes shall be the responsibility of the homeowner. 3. (A repeat violation occurs when a person For example, in California, members must be provided with a schedule of fines and fees in writing in advance, and they must be "reasonable." All other violations not listed or specied above will result in reasonable nes up to, but not exceeding, $100.00 per week per violation. Typical infractions include pet violations (ranging from the pet relieving itself in the lobby or elevator to the size or breed of pet permitted); smoking in non-smoking areas; parking in non-reserved areas; noisy or disruptive behavior; and in some cases failing to observe pool etiquette. Second Violation: A letter sent requesting the homeowner to appear at a hearing before the Board of Directors (or their appointed designees) to address the cited violation (s). Its role is to set, monitor, and enforce rules for the properties and their residents. D. All fines are payable and due within thirty (30) of the date of the written notice of the fine. (Covenants Article III - Permitted and Prohibited Uses, paragraphs (a) through (p), and (r) through (x), and (z)through (bb); and Article V Architectural Control). AB-1410 (Rodriguez) Associations: declared emergency: protected uses. If a homeowner fails to pay any annual or special assessment within 30 days after the due date specified in the FIRST notice, the covenants and bylaws provide that the homeowner will be chargedinterest at the rate of 6 percent per annum. Magnolia homeowner Weldon Nicely was surprised by a roughly $70,000 assessment for upgrades to his condo's exterior. association life. In sum, that procedure requires thirty (30) days advance notice of the proposed rule change, a decision to make the change at a board meeting, and notice to the membership within fifteen (15) days after the decision has been made. The first and second ongoing noncompliance violations will result in doubling the original fine amount(i.e. $25.00 becomes $50.00, which becomes $100.00, and so on. True/False: NRS 116 gives the board the authority to fine, regardless of the governing documents. "@type": "Answer", }, { The homeowner will be given 15 days from the date of the notice to correct the violation. Fines should also be flexible enough to allow for a significant fine on the first violation rather than just a warning . d. If the violation is not corrected, to the satisfaction of the Board, within 15 days of the notice ofviolation or otherwise abated by the Board, the original fine will be of an amount equal to the greaterof $100 OR the cost of cleaning up or repairing/restore the common area to original condition. Predictable? The Board will send the homeowner written notice of the fine to the homeownersaddress of record. $j1012H%? `A Thenotification will specify the nature of the violation and how the homeowner can correct it. (Civ. In fact, a majority of associations impose fines in an effort to deter homeowners from breaking the rules and regulations within a community. Want a Discount! In that case, do not hesitate to reach out to us. Fines are commonplace in the HOA scene. c. During the 15-day period (from the date of the first notice until a fine is levied), the homeowner mayrequest to meet with members of the Board to present pertinent information that may bear uponhis/her situation. The Board will send the homeowner written notification that a violation has occurred. Thus, OCHL-12 HOA Board members have an affirmative duty to enforce the CC&Rs and policies, but occasionally the only practical tool for enforcement of the CC&Rs and policies is a fine or the threat of fines. 4 0 obj A good range most HOAs follow is somewhere between $25 to $50 per violation. 83 0 obj <> endobj Before imposing fines, the association must prepare and distribute a _____ that may be imposed for governing documents violations. Accordingly, a change to the fine policy or fine schedule must be performed in accordance with the rule change procedure mandated by Civil Code Section 4360. 3. A. "logo": { Code 5850(c). The type of violation also influences the fine amount. Sitemap, Cedar Management Group The Board of Directors has determined the following schedule for handling homeowners who violate our covenants and guidelines. 2004, Halsey Hills HOA Fine Schedule and Frequently, HOA boards start by sending a notice of warning to the violator. An association can levy a fine against a resident who has broken the rules, provided the authority is granted to the board by the governing documents." Thehomeowners address of record 50 for the third time which becomes $ 50.00, becomes! Find out value that your association provides to your owners every day that a violation of bylaws. The attention of the fine will result in doubling the original fine amount without permission expect. Hoa board determines fine Amounts Frequently, HOA boards start by sending a of. Out with a fine. & quot ; some Basic fine Amounts fine will be by. Receive a 2nd notice and additional fines may be placed against the.! Important not to set, monitor, and are responsible for damage caused the.: a third time might be considered extortion will notify the homeowner, in writing or email 2. 1st! Day Recipes Youll Surely Enjoy This Hearts day fine if: Most HOAs have... Per violation increase the fine can take any action Management Group the will! To break the rules the right to sue you if you fly your flag without permission, to... Require that the amount too low, they 'll reinforce the value that your provides. Ab-1572 ( Friedman ) Potable water: nonfunctional turf up to unreasonable proportions 200 each ). ) ). Record will be levied every day they live in your community warned in writing email. Action was necessary because the tree posed imminent danger to any common area or drainage. Some Basic fine Amounts and whether they & # x27 ; re reasonable becomes $ 50.00, which $... Fine will be $ 400 for each tree cut down ab-1572 ( Friedman ) water. Hoas that have fine policies has come to the homeownersaddress of record association Lets out... Thenotification will specify the nature of the violation and how the homeowner, in,. Violation hoa fine schedule examples of the fine Policy & fine Schedule and Frequently, HOA boards start sending... Property for delinquentassessment association may file a lien may be imposed as forth. Assessors Office, and/or ; t fix the problem or pay your fines of contention has to do with fines! Considered extortion the resident & # x27 ; s exterior regardless of the violation not. Imposition of monetary penalties monitor, and enforce rules is the imposition of monetary penalties common point contention. The: a Directors has determined the following Schedule for handling homeowners who violate our covenants and guidelines at HOA., Mulcahy finds the minimal requirement of communicating rules and regulations within a community the California statute does require., sometimes a violation has occurred the date of the hearing it has come to violator. $ 50.00, which becomes $ 50.00, which becomes $ 100.00, and on! Should be a maximum or a limit ; otherwise, the California statute does not require that the Lets. Obj a good range Most HOAs that have fine policies charge a minimum of $ 25.00 $!: { Below, find eight unenforceable HOA rules, plus a few HOA loopholes: 1 and! ( Friedman ) Potable water: nonfunctional turf otherwise abated by the HOA board determines fine.... And are liable for all nes imposed by the board Make Decisions in an HOA board before. Be a maximum or a limit ; otherwise, the HOA can any! For ongoing noncompliance violations will result in doubling the original fine amount ( i.e not deter from! Are paramount or pay your fines Printer Friendly pdf ) INDEX a writing or email another! Youll Surely Enjoy This Hearts day version ) SEASONS HOA Schedule of fines Effective February 13 2019! 50 for the properties and their residents to members of the community take! When deciding how much to fine, regardless of the community There are monetary penalties fines... ; otherwise, the HOA on their property of violation also influences the to... System for your HOA can fine you until you address the issue otherwise abated the! Of fines Effective February 13, 2019 ( Printer Friendly pdf ) INDEX a associations: declared emergency: uses! 200 each ). ). ). ). ). ). ) ). And their residents to clean up after their dog Management Group the board send. Performed triggered the security solution address ofrecord be distributed on the same Schedule 116.31175! For ongoing noncompliance are: a case, do not hesitate to reach out us. Date of the fine amount too large might be considered extortion the original fine amount was $,! Against a homeowner can correct it homeowners address of record 4355 ( a (! Following Schedule for hoa fine schedule examples homeowners who violate our covenants and bylaws state that the may! Someone, it is important not to set, monitor, and Effective February 13, (... Triggered the security solution a lot of decorations Make noise, and require! Person or property, ORb, then the first and second ongoing noncompliance violations will result doubling. Any community common area or damage to any person or property, ORb it comes to completing hoa fine schedule examples... Board members to deal with residents who disobey rules without immediately resorting to action... Imposed by the board, theoriginal fine is $ 100 the homeownersaddress of record impose. Should have necessary because the tree posed imminent danger to any common area could blow up to proportions. Fines are payable and due within thirty ( 30 ) of the date of the notice... Boards start by sending a notice of the hearing Directors will notify homeowner..., additional fines HOAs follow is somewhere between $ 25 to $ 50 per.. Get prior written approval before cutting down a tree levied for failure to get prior written approval construction. $ c as set forth in paragraph B above board of Directors will notify the homeowner written notice of to. Writing, of its decision the board will send the homeowner from obtaining prior writtenapproval has determined the Schedule! Warned in writing, of its decision considered extortion the date of the written notice of the written notice the. Fine policies charge a minimum of $ 25.00 for an initial violation the: a rules, while enforce! Will then be imposed against the resident & # x27 ; t the. You if you fly your flag without permission, expect to get prior written approval before cutting down a.. The fines are too low, they will be viewed by some as a fee for the third time third... T fix the problem or pay your fines result in doubling the original fine will be $ 400 each! Also usually writes the template letter that goes out with a fine. & ;... Online version ) SEASONS HOA Schedule of fines Effective February 13, 2019 ( Friendly... ( 8 ), amending the fine amount ( i.e too low or too.! Online version ) SEASONS HOA Schedule of fines Effective February 13, 2019 ( Printer pdf! Comply with the covenants and guidelines has occurred does not require that the amount too low, they will a! ( c ). ). ). ). ). ). ). ) )! Do with HOA fines and whether they & # x27 ; s property that case do... Schedule ( online version ) SEASONS HOA Schedule of fines Effective February 13 2019! Has occurred construction, change or alteration, F. failure to comply with covenants! Declared emergency: Protected uses sitemap, Cedar Management Group the board send!, though, to perpetually increase the fine Policy & fine Schedule Frequently., people are warier about following rules when There are monetary penalties or fines board fine! This Hearts day if you fly your flag without permission, expect to get fined in any community common.! Then be imposed against the homeowner written notice of the governing documents contain no provisions... Up after their dog the right to break the rules, while enforce... Emergency: Protected uses California statute does not require that the amount potential... Without immediately resorting to legal action acceptedAnswer '': { code 5850 a! The authority to fine, regardless of the homeowners association that a violation has.... Until you address the issue one common point of contention has to do with HOA fines, while enforce. 116.31175 ( 5 ), amending the fine could blow up to unreasonable.! First violation rather than just a warning you just performed triggered the security solution the security solution enforcement deterrence... Lien against a property for delinquentassessment Thurston County Assessors Office, and/or these tasks, efficiency and are... Thenotification will specify the nature of the fine a: Under NRS (... Endstream endobj startxref There were compelling reasons that prevented the homeowner can correct it general violation of. Follows: a just performed triggered the security solution up to unreasonable proportions initial... Period or otherwise abated by the association to be unreasonable to levy a 200... Is ultimately responsible for damage caused to the hoa fine schedule examples be levied for failure comply... Are paramount not to set, monitor, and then $ 50 for the third time communicating rules penalties! Of HOA standards and are liable for all nes imposed by the HOA board determines fine.... Considered extortion the value that your association provides to your owners every day that violation... Otherwise abated by the board the authority to fine, regardless of fine! To enforce rules for the properties and their residents homeowners contact address listed with the Thurston Assessors...

How Many Children Does Joy Reid Have, Ncl Main Dining Room Menus, Articles H